Select Wisdom Brand

Why Did God Create People, Knowing They Would Sin?

by Stephen Davey

Steve Asked:

Since God is all knowing, why would he create something that he knew would fail.

Steve, this is one of the most profound questions that believers and skeptics alike wrestle with: "Why did God create people, knowing they would sin against Him?" From a Christian perspective, this question touches on the very nature of God, His intentions in creating humanity, and the purpose of life itself.

The Nature of God: Love and Relationship

At the heart of God's character is love. 1 John 4:8 tells us, "God is love." This love is not passive or conditional; it is active, seeking, and sacrificial. Christians believe that God created humans not out of necessity or loneliness but as an expression of His overflowing love, desiring to share His love and have a relationship with beings made in His image (Genesis 1:26-27).

The Gift of Free Will

For love to be genuine, it must be freely given and received. Therefore, God endowed humans with free will—the ability to choose or reject Him. A world where love is predetermined or forced is a world without true love at all. Thus, the risk of rebellion and sin was inherent in the gift of free will. Christians assert that God deemed the risk worthwhile, valuing the genuine relationships that would emerge from creatures who freely chose to love Him.

The Foreknowledge of Sin and the Plan of Redemption

God, in His omniscience, knew that humanity would misuse free will, leading to sin and separation from Him. Yet, His foreknowledge did not deter His creative work. Instead, it set the stage for the greatest demonstration of His love: the plan of redemption through Jesus Christ. Ephesians 1:4-5 reveals that God chose us in Christ "before the foundation of the world," indicating that the plan for redemption was not an afterthought but an integral part of God's purpose from the beginning.

The Purpose of Life and the Call to Relationship

The Christian perspective sees the human experience, marred though it is by sin, as an opportunity for growth, learning, and ultimately, redemption. Life for the believer is a journey of becoming more like Christ. We have been invited to experience God's love, grace, and forgiveness firsthand. The reality of sin highlights the need for a Savior, drawing us to a deeper understanding of God's love and mercy.

The Glory of God Revealed

Lastly, God's decision to create, knowing the inevitability of sin, serves to reveal His glory in a way that would have been impossible otherwise. In the face of human rebellion, God's attributes—His holiness, justice, mercy, and grace—are displayed in full. The redemption story showcases God's sovereignty and the lengths to which He will go to restore His relationship with humanity.


In conclusion, from an evangelical perspective, the question "Why did God create people, knowing they would sin against Him?" finds its answer in the nature of God's love, the gift of free will, and the overarching story of redemption. Though sin introduced pain and suffering into God's good creation, it also set the stage for the display of God's grace, mercy, and love through Jesus Christ. Humanity's creation, fall, and redemption narrative invites everyone into a deeper, more meaningful relationship with their Creator, where the true essence of life is found.

Add a Comment