Is God responsible for evil?

Russell asks, “Is God responsible for plagues, viruses and deaths, or is Satan responsible?”

I’ve been asked many variations of the question, “How could a loving God allow …” The idea of a good and perfect and holy God allowing—or perhaps even causing—tragedy and death in this world is no easy thing to explain away.

There are two premises that all believers must accept that are the foundation for answering this question:

  1. God is sovereign over all circumstances and God is perfect and holy. He is all these things all the time, and no attribute of God diminishes any other.
  2. Whenever our human understanding cannot reconcile two attributes of God that seem to compete with each other, the fault is not with God, but with our human understanding.

To answer your question directly, God is not responsible for the consequences of sin in the world: we are. But God does use and often does cause these consequences—like plagues, viruses, and death—to happen.

To put it in slightly different terms, is a judge is responsible for a criminal receiving a prison sentence? That judge may have caused the guilty person to go to prison by issuing the sentence, but the guilty person is responsible for the consequences of their own actions, their own crimes.

Through our sin, humanity is morally responsible for all evil in the world. But none of these consequences can exist without the will and sovereignty of God.

Remember, it was God, through Moses, who brought the plagues—including death—upon the Egyptians. Satan wasn’t working through Moses, God was.

It was God who gave Satan permission to inflict harm upon Job; Satan couldn’t even do that without asking God’s allowance.

When we see evil in the world, we can recognize that God is sovereign over even that evil, and we can seek ways God might be working through even tragedy; but we cannot blame God. We can only look at our sins—the sins of the whole world—and grieve over the consequences of those sins.

But ultimately, we can rejoice that God has provided us an eternal rescue from both sin and judgment: His son, Jesus Christ.

Comments

Joel Haubenstock says:
Hi Brother, Thank you for your ministry! I agree with your comments. How do you factor in Isaiah 45:7 I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things.. Shalom Shalom (perfect peace) ❤️🙏

Add a Comment

How to use this page:

Here at Wisdom International, we believe that the Bible is God's Word. Therefore, it carries the authority of God himself and is the final authority by which we order our lives. 

Sometimes the Bible can be confusing and difficult to understand. But God desires to be known. Scripture answers the big questions of life and should seek to know and understand what it says. 

This section of our website contains Stephen Davey's articles and his ever-growing archive of answers to questions from people like you. If you have a Bible question and are seeking an answer from the Bible, use our contact form to submit your question for Stephen. 

If you have questions, the Bible has answers and we want to help you! Ask Stephen your question here

You can browse this section to read Stephen's previous answers and read all of his previous posts. To search and see if your question has already been answered, click on the search icon above.